单 Agent 与多 Agent 对比挑战
在同一任务下基于真实规划器 Token 核算对比单 Agent 与多 Agent 拓扑,拒绝为了显得高级而盲目堆砌 Agent。
规划器建议: 多 Agent 架构(实现 + 独立审查)
Two-Stage Build + Independent Audit Setup (balanced) pairing OpenAI o3 with Gemini 2.5 Pro.
Multi-Agent Delta: +145,456 tokens · +$0.3100 expected
单 Agent 架构
Alternative- 预估总 Token
- 310,246
- 交接开销 Token
- 0
- 预估成本区间
- $0.8006 – $1.4164
- 协调复杂度
- low (1 agent)
Models & Workflow
- Primary Execution Agent: OpenAI o3 (openai/o3)
- 1. Technical design & dependency plan (primary-agent)
- 2. Core implementation (primary-agent)
- 3. Independent security & QA audit (primary-agent)
- 4. Resolve findings & final verification (primary-agent)
优势
- Zero context handoff serialization overhead between separate agent loops.
- Lower estimated token usage and simpler debugging when a step needs adjustment.
- Shared working memory across planning, implementation, and self-verification.
局限
- Self-review happens in the same context window, which can miss subtle security or architectural blind spots on high-risk tasks.
- Single model handles both implementation and verification rather than pairing a specialist reviewer.
多 Agent 架构(实现 + 独立审查)
Recommended by Planner- 预估总 Token
- 455,702
- 交接开销 Token
- 58,137
- 预估成本区间
- $1.0424 – $1.9378
- 协调复杂度
- moderate (2 agents)
Models & Workflow
- Primary Builder Agent: OpenAI o3 (openai/o3)
- Independent Reviewer / Auditor Agent: Gemini 2.5 Pro (google_gemini/gemini-2.5-pro)
- 1. Technical design & dependency plan (builder-agent)
- 2. Core implementation (builder-agent)
- 3. Independent security & QA audit (verifier-agent)
- 4. Resolve findings & final verification (builder-agent)
优势
- Separates implementation from adversarial security, compliance, or QA verification.
- Allows routing high-reasoning or specialized verification to a dedicated reviewer model.
- Clear artifact handoff boundaries in an acyclic workflow DAG.
局限
- Adds ~58,137 estimated handoff tokens plus reviewer pass overhead.
- More configuration surface and extra coordination steps when a single agent would already suffice.
对比假设说明
- Both topologies evaluate the exact same task objective using the real AgentPilot planner and verified catalog pricing.
- Multi-Agent adds structured context handoff serialization plus an independent review pass; actual runs vary by repository size and retries.
- No quality benchmark percentages are fabricated; trade-offs reflect architectural structure and token accounting.